The release of the Hinman papers in the SEC’s case against Ripple is expected to benefit ether (ETH) and promote decentralization in the crypto market.
The Hinman documents may influence regulatory efforts, potentially leading to a new category for decentralized cryptocurrencies like ether.

The recent release of the Hinman papers in the ongoing case between the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Ripple is set to have a significant impact on ether (ETH) and drive greater decentralization within the crypto market, according to a research report by JPMorgan (JPM).

Emails associated with former Director of Corporation Finance William Hinman’s 2018 speech, which stated that ether did not resemble a security, were published last Tuesday by Ripple as part of its defense against the SEC lawsuit.

JPMorgan’s research report highlighted that senior SEC officials did not categorize ether as a security in 2018. The report also noted that the SEC acknowledged the existence of an “other category,” recognizing that tokens on a sufficiently decentralized network no longer qualified as securities, thereby creating a regulatory gap.

Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou, leading the team of analysts, referred to the Howey Test, which determines if transactions qualify as investment contracts under U.S. securities laws. The absence of a controlling group in ether, as defined by the Howey Test, contributed to its classification as “not a security.” However, Panigirtzoglou emphasized the potential need for regulation to protect purchasers despite this distinction.

JPMorgan suggests that these revelations could explain why the SEC has not taken action against ether while targeting other crypto tokens this year. The Hinman documents are expected to influence ongoing congressional efforts to regulate the crypto industry, potentially preventing the designation of ether as a security.

To streamline regulation, JPMorgan proposes placing ether in the same category as bitcoin (BTC), treating it as a commodity overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). Additionally, the bank suggests the introduction of a new “other category” specifically tailored to decentralized cryptocurrencies like ether. The level of decentralization would be a determining factor in avoiding security classification.

The release of the Hinman papers is predicted to intensify competition among major cryptocurrencies as they strive to become more decentralized and resemble ether. The report suggests that the industry will witness a trend toward increased decentralization as cryptocurrencies aim to avoid being classified as securities and benefit from the regulatory advantages associated with being decentralized.

The impact of the Hinman papers extends beyond the immediate legal battle, setting the stage for regulatory developments and promoting a shift toward greater decentralization in the crypto market, particularly as more cryptocurrencies seek to emulate the characteristics of ether.

---

Filed under: Bitcoin - @ June 19, 2023 10:00 am